[Valdacil]

That was excellent information regarding how the plugins are supposed to save their settings. I can confirm that I do NOT have a PluginsData directory under my LotRO folder.

Had RKS not been having the same problem I might have suspected that it had something to do with the fact that my "My Documents" folder is located on a network share (I have a domain server which enforces folder redirection via group policy). For the most part this hasn't caused a problem with modern software, though I did have some problems with older software.

[Edit]
I just reread RKS's post. RKS: You are currently operating as expected. Loaded plugins do not currently reload upon logout/login. You will need to reload your plugins each login. I recommend getting one of the plugin managers posted in another forum and making a shortcut on your quickslot bar to load the manager. You should then be able to reload all your plugins in a few seconds after each login.

So now we're back to is My Documents redirection confusing LotRO? Unless anyone else has other theories. I would hate to have to log out of my computer and log into a local account just to play LotRO.